Business catalogNew YorkRanking 2026
Orthopedic surgeon New York
Our subjective pick: the best Orthopedic surgeon in New York.
- Companies ranked
- 13 Companies
- Average rating
- 4,7 Avg. rating
- Edition year
- 2026 Edition
Updated 20 czerwca 2026
Company ranking
13 places- 014,9(1216 reviews)Portal score 8,6
Patients generally report high satisfaction with the medical expertise and bedside manner of the surgeons, who are frequently praised for their clear communication and conservative treatment approaches. However, some patients experience significant frustration regarding long wait times and difficulties in communicating with administrative or surgical coordination staff.
- Knowledgeable and clear communication
- Conservative treatment options
- Compassionate bedside manner
- 024,9(1359 reviews)Portal score 8,6
Patients generally report high satisfaction with the medical staff's expertise, thorough communication, and efficient care. However, significant concerns exist regarding administrative issues, specifically regarding billing errors and difficulty reaching the office staff.
- Knowledgeable and thorough medical staff
- Minimal wait times for appointments
- Friendly and professional providers
- 034,9(571 reviews)Portal score 8,6
Patients consistently praise Dr. Jonathan Glashow for his exceptional surgical skill, knowledgeable approach, and attentive post-operative care. The practice is highly regarded for its supportive staff and effective physical therapy services, with many patients returning for multiple procedures over several years.
- Highly skilled surgical expertise
- Attentive post-operative care
- Knowledgeable and supportive staff
- 044,9(402 reviews)Portal score 8,5
Patients consistently praise Dr. Mulchandani for his thorough explanations, patient-centered approach, and genuine compassion during both surgical and non-surgical care. The office staff is frequently noted for being efficient, courteous, and helpful in managing administrative tasks like insurance verification.
- Thorough and clear explanations
- Patient and attentive bedside manner
- Responsive and professional office staff
- 054,9(173 reviews)Portal score 8,2
Patients consistently report high satisfaction with Dr. Steven Struhl's orthopedic surgical expertise, particularly regarding shoulder and AC joint procedures. Reviewers frequently highlight successful recovery outcomes, minimal scarring, and the supportive, efficient nature of his office staff.
- Highly skilled surgical expertise
- Effective and fast recovery
- Attentive and professional staff
- 064,7(241 reviews)Portal score 8,1
Dr. Tehrany is widely praised for his surgical expertise in knee and shoulder procedures, with many patients reporting successful recoveries and improved quality of life. While the majority of reviews highlight a caring and professional staff, a small subset of patients reported issues with communication and bedside manner.
- Successful knee and shoulder surgeries
- Knowledgeable and caring staff
- Thorough explanation of procedures
- 074,8(134 reviews)Portal score 8,0
Patients consistently report high satisfaction with the medical staff, highlighting thorough communication and compassionate care. The practice is frequently praised for its ability to provide clear explanations and effective surgical outcomes.
- Thorough and clear explanations
- Compassionate and attentive care
- Effective surgical outcomes
- 084,6(187 reviews)Portal score 8,0
Patients generally report high satisfaction with the medical expertise and bedside manner of the physicians at New York Bone & Joint Specialists. While the clinical care is frequently praised, experiences with administrative staff and appointment wait times are inconsistent.
- Knowledgeable and thorough physicians
- Helpful and attentive front desk staff
- Easy appointment booking via Zocdoc
- 094,7(154 reviews)Portal score 8,0
Patients generally report high satisfaction with Dr. Gupta's surgical expertise, clear communication, and compassionate bedside manner. While most experiences are positive, some patients have encountered significant challenges with administrative responsiveness and office staff interactions.
- Clear explanation of treatment
- Compassionate bedside manner
- Successful surgical outcomes
- 104,9(55 reviews)Portal score 7,7
Dr. Eric Strauss is consistently praised for his exceptional surgical skill, compassionate bedside manner, and high level of personal attentiveness. Patients frequently report successful outcomes for complex knee and shoulder procedures and appreciate his willingness to provide direct communication throughout the treatment process.
- Personalized follow-up phone calls
- Clear explanation of treatment options
- Highly skilled orthopedic surgery
- 114,9(87 reviews)Portal score 7,7
Dr. Eric Grossman is widely praised for his surgical skill, patient-centered communication, and thorough explanations regarding hip and knee procedures. While the vast majority of patients report successful outcomes and high satisfaction, one patient reported a negative surgical experience and dissatisfaction with post-operative care.
- thorough patient explanations
- responsive office staff
- effective hip and knee replacements
- 124,9(52 reviews)Portal score 7,7
Patients consistently report high satisfaction with Dr. Sean Thompson and his staff, highlighting his expertise in orthopedic and robotic surgery. The practice is frequently praised for its clear communication, thorough patient consultations, and effective surgical outcomes.
- Thorough and informative consultations
- Professional and caring office staff
- Effective surgical outcomes
- 134,6(70 reviews)Portal score 7,6
Patients consistently praise Dr. John Kennedy as a highly skilled and compassionate surgeon who successfully treats complex foot and ankle injuries. While his clinical expertise and bedside manner are widely lauded, some patients note that his practice does not participate in insurance plans.
- Exceptional bedside manner
- Expertise in complex surgical revisions
- Clear communication of medical conditions
Company comparison
Frequently asked questions
- How do I choose the best orthopedic surgeons in New York?
- To find the best provider, start by reviewing our curated list of 18 orthopedic surgeons in New York. We recommend comparing their areas of specialization and patient feedback to ensure they align with your specific medical needs.
- What should I look for when selecting an orthopedic surgeon?
- Look for a surgeon who is board-certified and has extensive experience with your specific injury or condition. You can start your search with our top-rated provider, City Orthopedics - Manhattan, led by Dr. Neil Mulchandani, who currently holds a 4.9/5 rating.
- How should I interpret ratings and reviews for orthopedic surgeons?
- When reading reviews, focus on patient experiences regarding communication, recovery outcomes, and office staff professionalism. While the average rating for the category is currently unavailable, individual scores like the 4.9/5 rating for City Orthopedics - Manhattan can serve as a helpful benchmark.
- What can I expect during my first visit to an orthopedic surgeon?
- During your initial consultation, the surgeon will typically perform a physical examination and review your medical history or imaging results. Be prepared to discuss your pain levels and functional goals so the doctor can create an appropriate treatment plan.
- What is a practical tip for finding the right orthopedic care in 2026?
- A practical tip is to verify if the surgeon accepts your specific health insurance plan before scheduling an appointment. Prices for procedures vary depending on the complexity of your condition and the specific treatment required, so always confirm costs with the office directly.